Where were you when LeBron James made The Decision? I sure hope in 10, 20, or 30 years no one will ask me this. But I have a feeling someone will… (Let me document it now – I was sitting in Columbia University’s East Campus dorm, room 1210, illegally streaming ESPN on my Apple laptop and simultaneously watching So You Think You Can Dance, no judgement please).
This is my decision on The Decision: it was the most hyped hour of television (Lost was two plus hours, so don’t say I’m wrong) of my life, it was the most disappointing hour of television of my life, and it was the longest hour of television of my life. I placed a bet LeBron would announce at 9:03 he was staying with the Cavs – now you see why I feel the way I do. Thank God the bet was only a few bucks (and it was a bet NO ONE in the pool of sports journos won, that’s saying something).
But I’m just a fan (interns lack credentials, therefore I get fan status), and, sadly, in the sports world, the fan’s opinion matters less and less each year. So whose opinion does matter? The pros of the media and NBA. Here is what some of them thought about the lasting legacy of The Decision…
About LeBron:
In no way does Jordan join a superstar like Wade. LeBron doesn’t have the competitive fire to even be mentioned in the same breath as Michael Jordan. – Bleacher Report
James is a genius for what he engineered with Wade and Bosh. – FanNation
LeBron played with fire – unnecessarily. – PR Inside
James’ team isn’t saying how much in total was raised, but Maverick Carter, CEO of LRMR, did say on Thursday afternoon that more than $2 million in net proceeds will go to the Boys & Girls Club of America. Vitaminwater and Nike also contributed in the charitable effort. – CNBC.com
Everybody can say what they want — it was the wrong decision, there was too much hoopla, whatever — but for me it was about doing the event, getting the advertisers to participate and doing it for charity. – Ad Age
About ESPN:
ESPN has just sent a message to CAA, IMG, Scott Boras, etc., that they are OPEN FOR BUSINESS! for ‘news’ announcements. – NY Daily News
It was a ratings hit, so don’t be surprised if we see more packaged programs of free agents announcing their next stop in prime time. – USA Today
I’m keeping my 2 yr old up to watch the LeBron James Special. I want her to see the exact moment our society hit rock bottom. – Sports Illustrated
About the NBA:
The face of the NBA has now turned into one of the biggest villains in sports. Things could not be worse for LeBron’s image right now. – Bleacher Report
For the first time in league history, players themselves, not an owner or general manager, put together a championship team. – FanNation
Here is the thing about opinions – everyone is entitled to one, and usually no one opinion is right or wrong. But I think in this situation there will be an evident right and wrong (dependent on multiple factors including if LeBron gets rings, how other players handle their free agencies, if ESPN starts dishing out hour specials, etc.). Problem is, no one will be able to see this evidence for years to come. And by then – who really cares? There is no need to have an ultimate decision about The Decision. LeBron will still be a talented basketball millionaire, and we will all still be willing witnesses of whatever court the King decides to hold.

